AI judging of IOTD, TPN etc AstroBin Platform open discussions community forum · Leela.Astro.Imaging · ... · 39 · 1160 · 3

WhooptieDo 10.40
...
· 
·  4 likes
·  Share link
No
Like
kv54 1.81
...
· 
·  1 like
·  Share link
Hi all,

With 25 years experience in machine vision I can say that AI is the solution for many problems in industry. But performance depends on training data. Based on this, don't expect too much, when the training is done by input from the current judges…

CS,

Klaus
Like
kv54 1.81
...
· 
·  Share link
*deleted*
Edited ...
Like
Christophorus 12.36
...
· 
·  7 likes
·  Share link
Hi Klaus,

what do you want to tell us with your post. It listens like 74 members of the IOTD team have the wrong taste and no capability to pic out the correct pics for the process, but you have. I am the opinion you can not accept the rules and the purpose of the IOTD. It is to show the most stunning results taken by amateurs without regarding the effort, the circumstances, the equipment and the skills of the fotographer. Further on, Astrobin is a social platform for showing astropics, communication, sharing information, finding friends. It is not a platform for assesing the value of your astrofotographical work. In addition please stop to insult the team members.

best, Christoph Lichtblau, judge
Like
kv54 1.81
...
· 
·  Share link
Hi Christoph,


critics on IOTD judges is allowed and necessary to ensure objective judgement.

If you cannot stand it, feel free to leave this board. Everyone can be replaced.

I pay 65 Euro per year for this. And I will always open my mouth, if I want it!!!


Klaus
Like
Christophorus 12.36
...
· 
·  4 likes
·  Share link
Dear Klaus,

I for sure will not leave this platform, I am happy with it. You are the one who is complaining all the time.


Christoph
Like
AstroStew 0.90
...
· 
·  2 likes
·  Share link
This constant moaning about the IOTD is getting so f****** tedious, why the hell does the site owner allow it, for f**** sake just sort this out, it’s so boring, reading all the childish comments, it’s like primary school arguments, from grown adults….
Edited ...
Like
siovene
...
· 
·  1 like
·  Share link
AstroStew:
why the hell does the site owner allow it

Hi, site owner here. Because I don't think it's a good idea to delete comments that critique AstroBin. It will look like censorship.

My job is to address critique, and I have responded to such so many times. These specific complaints are covered in the FAQ too, as it's something that comes up often.

As you can see by responses by other people here, the majority of the community understands now the reasons why the IOTD/TP is not split in categories, probably thanks to a lot of past posts, and the FAQ. A vocal minority of hardcore opponents remain, but I don't think I should remove their voice.

Please keep in mind that these posts are relegated to the group AstroBin Platform open discussions community forum that is not mandatory to join. People not in the group don't see such posts in the "Recent topics" list.

@kv54, all I can do is invite you gently to stop complaining. Your opinion has been heard and answered. Repeated posts about this subject is really not doing anything positive.

Thanks!
Like
HegAstro 14.24
...
· 
·  1 like
·  Share link
AstroStew:
This constant moaning about the IOTD is getting so f****** tedious, why the hell does the site owner allow it, for f**** sake just sort this out, it’s so boring, reading all the childish comments, it’s like primary school arguments, from grown adults….

as tempting as it is to respond to the constant complaining, sometimes it is best to ignore it, especially if it is the same person doing it. You have to realize that you cannot satisfy everyone. There will always be discontents. For what it is worth, I have done my fair share of complaining, but there is far more good here than bad.
Like
AstroStew 0.90
...
· 
·  Share link
Maybe you should just get AI to moderate the forum, as it seems no one else is doing so
Like
siovene
...
· 
·  1 like
·  Share link
AstroStew:
Maybe you should just get AI to moderate the forum, as it seems no one else is doing so

I am moderating the forums, I just am more permissive than you, probably. Please let me repeat it: you are on a forum called "AstroBin Platform open discussions community forum", so people will discuss about AstroBin features, and sometimes complain about something they don't like. This forum is optional, you joined the group and this is why you see these posts.

I am not going to moderate away posts with complaints, I don't think that's the right thing to do.
Edited ...
Like
kv54 1.81
...
· 
·  Share link
Hi Salvatore,

thanks for clarification. Please note, that I decide by myself, when to stop anything. Nobody is forced to listen or to reply. 

Seeing the reactions of some of the judges encourages me to go on with this discussion.


CS,

Klaus
Like
AstroStew 0.90
...
· 
·  Share link
Salvatore Iovene:
AstroStew:
Maybe you should just get AI to moderate the forum, as it seems no one else is doing so

I am moderating the forums, I just am more permissive than you, probably. Please let me repeat it: you are on a forum called "AstroBin Platform open discussions community forum", so people will discuss about AstroBin features, and sometimes complain about something they don't like. This forum is optional, you joined the group and this is why you see these posts.

I am not going to moderate away posts with complaints, I don't think that's the right thing to do.

Ok, no problem I will leave. It’s just so off putting coming in here hitting the new latest posts button to have a catch up, and seeing half the page full of idiots moaning about the IOTD or other stupid meaningless topics 🤷🏼‍♂️
Like
siovene
...
· 
·  Share link
AstroStew:
It’s just so off putting coming in here hitting the new latest posts button to have a catch up

I agree, but it's just a wave and it's literally one person. It shall pass.
Like
siovene
...
· 
·  Share link
This topic is now closed. The initial question did not prompt a technical discussion on the feasibility of this idea, as I believe the original poster intended, and in any case this idea is not aligned with the AstroBin roadmap and ideology. As the recent posts have been going off-topic, I don't see any value in keeping this post open.

Thanks for understanding!
Like
 
This topic was closed by a moderator.