The cause and the elimination of halos around stars with some duo-narrowband filters Other · Walter Leonhard Schramböck · ... · 27 · 900 · 13

lduchene 1.43
...
· 
·  Share link
Walter Leonhard Schramböck:
Bildschirmfoto 2024-09-22 um 21.14.47.png
I had this problem with two of my dual narrowband filters: huge halos around some stars, although I noticed that the affected stars are not always the visually brightest in the image. I also noticed in the last series of photographs that it seems to be particularly bad for stars that shine strongly in the red spectrum. My suspicion: the filter coatings have a problem in the infrared spectrum, something unpleasant is happening that leads to this false light - whatever it is.
My two affected filter candidates are: the Optolong L-extreme and the dual narrowband filter from ZWO.
As a test, I installed a UV/IR-cut filter from Baader in front of the dual narrow-band filter from ZWO, and the halos were actually completely eliminated.
So if you also have this problem, just try it out and see if it helps. 

I have to mention: this is happening at f2 with my Samyang 135mm Lens. Probably f2 is amplifying any halo-related filter-problems.

I released both filters from it's housing and installed both as a stack in the holder from baader because there is more space. UV/IR-cut filter at the scope-side, dual-narrowband at the sensor-side.

It worked perfectly well for me, what do you think? Does the light-transmission suffer significantly with this approach?

IMG_6679.JPG

Picture shows the installed filter-stack.

Had a similar issue with my Samayng lens and used a similar approach but instead with a Hoya 55mm filter in front of the lens that also acts as an aperture to bring the lens closer to F/2.8 without diffraction spikes.

Worked well enough for me but had similar questions about stacking filters and could not really get to a satisfying answer yet.

IMG-20231204-WA0002.jpg
Edited ...
Like
char32geek 2.11
...
· 
·  Share link
Jeff Reitzel:
The filter you reference from Astronomik is a 45nm visual filter designed specifically to enhance comet and emission nebula visual observation. It was never designed for deep sky photography and does not have the same IR coatings as other filters specifically designed for photography.


I knew someone would not understand the "apples to oranges" statement.  Astronomik lists photography as one of it's uses, and the filter itself is listed on this page:  https://www.astronomik.com/en/photographic-filters.html
Like
walter.leonhard 1.20
Topic starter
...
· 
·  Share link
Your halos look similar to what I was experiencing in my tests I wrote about earlier here:
https://www.astrobin.com/forum/c/astrophotography/equipment/askar-c2-filter-halo-tests-with-nir-sensitive-osc-cameras/

I'm curious to know if you are using an IMX585 or IMX533 sensor?

I am using the ZWO ASI183MC-Pro for the Samyang.
Like
 
Register or login to create to post a reply.